There’s no query that Cancun and Punta Cana are two of the preferred locations for an all-inclusive trip. Cancun is probably the most visited Destinations in Mexico, whereas Punta Cana is probably the most visited vacation spot within the Dominican Republic. Each location affords guests a big selection of all-inclusive properties at costs that vary from ultra-luxurious to completely inexpensive. Both locations have been breaking records this summer season, proving that vacationers are flocking to the areas. For those that are on the fence about which space to decide on, this text will assist decide a winner!
Travel Off Path has pitted every location towards one another in a head-to-head comparability to find out one of the best all-inclusive vacation spot. For readability, we’ve damaged issues down into sections, together with pricing and resort choices, seashores, climate, actions, security, in addition to flight connectivity and value, and traveler curiosity.
For this comparability, we assumed a one-week trip throughout January, a peak journey month for each areas. Specifically, we selected January 14th to January 21st, with flights out and in on every of these days as nicely. All costs proven are primarily based on two folks touring collectively.
All Inclusive Costs & Options
One of the driving decision-making elements for holidays is price, so it’s value exploring how Cancun and Punta Cana rank towards one another. To make the comparability of properties related to extra than simply luxurious vacationers, we are going to discover two classes; 4-star properties & 5-star properties. Average prices had been discovered utilizing reserving.com and the dates of January 14th by way of January 21st.
Only all-inclusive properties had been thought-about, and pricing knowledge was pulled on September 5th. We combed by way of all obtainable properties to get a mean price of every class, and the outcomes are beneath:
4-Star Stack up
Number of Available 4-Star All Inclusives
- Cancun: $276 per night time
- Punta Cana: $239 per night time
Average User Rating Out Of 10
- Cancun: 7.68
- Punta Cana: 7.22
5-Star Stack up
Number of Available 5-Star All Inclusives
- Cancun: $505 per night time
- Punta Cana: $422 per night time
Average User Rating Out Of 10
- Cancun: 8.46
- Punta Cana: 8.08
Pricing: Who Wins?
Based on common costs alone, Punta Cana has the higher hand on this class.
In whole, Cancun has 74 all inclusive properties to select from, whereas Punta Cana has 72. Cancun has extra 4-star choices than Punta Cana, implying extra affordability. However, on common, Cancun’s 4-star properties are over $30 extra per night time than Punta Cana. Similarly, Cancun’s 5-star properties are, on common, about $80 extra per night time than Punta Cana. This isn’t to say that Cancun has no inexpensive choices, although.
For occasion, the 4-star Hotel Dos Playas Faranda Cancún is simply $200 per night time for the dates explored. The most cost-effective choice for a 4-star keep in Punta Cana, the whala!bávaro, comes out somewhat extra inexpensive at $187 per night time. It must also be famous that, on common, Cancun’s 4-star and 5-star properties have barely increased consumer scores.
What’s a tropical trip and not using a lovely seaside? That first step onto that white-sand Caribbean seaside is sort of value the price of the flight alone. When selecting between Cancun or Punta Cana, it’s vital to know which has seashores higher suited to your journey type. We’ll break down the highest 5 seashores for every vacation spot and their variations. Beach rankings had been discovered utilizing Tripadvisor.
Top 5 Punta Cana Beaches
Top 5 Cancun Beaches
The single largest distinction between seaside days in Cancun vs. Punta Cana is the extent of improvement. In Cancun, the lengthy stretch of sand within the lodge zone is jam-packed with eating places, retailers, resorts, and infinite actions for vacationers to reap the benefits of.
Conversely, Punta Cana’s seashores are much less developed and provide a extra genuine tropical seaside vibe. While resorts actually dot the shores, it’s a lot simpler to discover a secluded stretch of sand to absorb the solar.
Beaches: Who Wins?
When it involves seashores, there’s no particular metric that may determine whether or not Cancun or Punta Cana is the final word winner. However, it could actually be an influencing issue when deciding which vacation spot is for you.
If you favor your seaside days to be near a seemingly infinite array of actions, Cancun could also be for you. The tradeoff is that the seashores will probably be way more busy and crowded. But if that’s your vibe, then Cancun is ideal!
Punta Cana will probably be a greater place for vacationers who wish to carve out their very own house on the seaside. However, the worth you’ll pay for fewer crowds and seclusion will probably be much less entry to facilities. That’s actually to not say there aren’t actions and eating places to attempt, merely that they don’t seem to be as condensed into one space as they’re in Cancun.
The attractive climate supplied by each Cancun and Punta Cana is among the many causes vacationers flock to those areas over the autumn and winter. Every week of sunshine and heat climate is a superb approach to break up the winter into extra manageable sections. January is the dry season for each places, and rain doesn’t have a tendency to stay round. For days that it does rain, it usually storms for a brief interval and rapidly goes again to lovely sunshine.
Below, now we have laid out common temperatures and different info for the month of January in every vacation spot.
- Average – 74.6°F (23.6°C)
- High – 77.7°F (25.4°C)
- Low – 72.3°F (22.4°C)
- Rainfall Average: 9 Days with Rain, averaging 3 inches (51mm)
- Average Humidity: 71%
- Average Water Temperature: 79°F (26°C)
- Average – 76.6°F (24.8°C)
- Low – 74.8°F (23.8°C)
- Rainfall Average: 11 Days with Rain, averaging 2 inches (51mm)
- Average Humidity: 76%
- Average Water Temperature: 80°F (27°C)
Weather: Who Wins?
Cancun and Punta Cana have such comparable averages in January that it’s troublesome to find out an final winner on this class. Both locations will provide a welcome respite from the chilly of winter. However, for individuals who don’t prefer it too scorching, Cancun could also be higher on common because of the decrease humidity ranges and barely decrease common temperatures.
Cancun and Punta Cana provide a variety of actions to get pleasure from throughout your keep. The most important distinction in choices is the type of actions obtainable. While there are various overlaps, corresponding to snorkeling, watersports, and swimming in cenotes, every vacation spot has its personal really feel and distinctive choices for vacationers to get pleasure from.
Cancun’s lodge zone is sort of a big 15-mile-long playground. It is the guts of tourism in Mexico and is designed to supply infinite leisure to these visiting its shores. Nightclubs, eating places, procuring malls, seaside golf equipment, and extra are all only a fast taxi journey or stroll away while you keep within the lodge zone. An intensive checklist of each exercise obtainable would require a number of pages, so we’ve listed a couple of of notice beneath:
- Xoximilco Cancun – A self-named “Floating Fiesta” awaits guests heading to Xoximilco. Guests board colorfully adorned gondolas with an open bar and a three-course meal. As you enterprise by way of the park’s canals, you will note many alternative bands and exhibits. This is only one of Cancun’s many dinner exhibits, but it surely actually units itself aside from the remainder!
- Nightlife – Cancun’s nightlife is unimaginable, and there are some wildly common locations to go. Coco Bongo is a should and is arguably Cancun’s most well-known nightclub. With reside performances, balloons, confetti, bubbles, full stage lighting, unimaginable music, and way more, visitors will benefit from the get together of a lifetime.
- Day Trips Galore – Not solely is Cancun itself filled with issues to do, but it surely additionally has easy accessibility to some fairly unimaginable day journeys. From Cenotes to historical ruins, many adventures await. Tulum is among the hottest day journeys, permitting guests to go to an historical Mayan archaeological web site.
Punta Cana Activities
Punta Cana is a wonderful place for vacationers who recognize the outside and have an adventurous spirit. While it additionally has nightlife choices, there aren’t almost as many as Cancun. For an adventurous day without work the resort, vacationers can journey ATVs by way of the inside forests, zipline by way of the bushes, swim in a cenote, or journey a horse on the seaside at sundown. Here are a couple of actions of notice in Punta Cana beneath:
- Scape Park – This 247-acre park is an effective way to participate in a bunch of outside actions multi function place. Swim in underground caves, zipline alongside a cliff, go caving, snorkel at Bucaneros reef, or float round within the turquoise waters of Hoyo Azul, a hidden cenote.
- Visit Saona Island – Saona Island lies off the southern coast of the Dominican Republic and is a nature reserve free from main improvement. If you need to really feel like you’re strolling alongside the seaside in an untouched tropical paradise, that is the place to do it. Day journeys embrace a ship journey to the island, usually with an open bar and a buffet lunch.
- Unique Night Life – While Punta Cana might not have as many choices as Cancun on the subject of nightlife, it actually has some distinctive ones. One of probably the most fascinating must be Imagine Cave Disco. Built proper into pure caves, this nightclub units the tone for what is bound to be a memorable night time.
Activities: Who Wins?
If we base the winner purely on the variety of actions supplied, then Cancun is a transparent winner. However, each traveler has their very own distinctive tastes once they go to a brand new place. For vacationers trying to spend extra time open air adventuring, Punta Cana often is the approach to go. Cancun is the best way to go for vacationers looking for a vacation spot that feels way more city and is teeming with infinite issues to do.
All inclusive properties in Cancun and Punta Cana are thought-about protected locations. When venturing away from the resorts nonetheless, guests ought to train elevated warning. The most typical crime affecting vacationers in each locations is petty theft. Criminals assume that vacationers have some huge cash, smartphones, jewellery, and different valuables.
The U.S State Department classifies The Dominican Republic and the Quintana Roo State (the place Cancun resides) as Level 2: Exercise Increased Caution. Advice from the state division for Level 2 areas consists of:
- Stay conscious of environment
- Do not resist a theft
- Don’t show indicators of wealth
- Follow native recommendation of resort or tour guides for security
Both nations must be protected for vacationers who stick with well-known vacationer areas and actions. However, by the numbers, Cancun comes out forward for security. Mexico has against the law rate of 54.19 whereas the Dominican Republic has against the law fee of 61.02. This signifies that per each 100,000 folks, 61 of them are topic to against the law within the Dominican Republic whereas 54 are topic to against the law in Mexico.
Flight Connectivity and Costs
Hotel and normal prices within the space are simply two items of the puzzle when planning a visit. Another sizeable piece is flight prices and the way simple it’s to get to the place you’re going. Below we’ve damaged down how well-connected Cancun and Punta Cana are to the United States and Canada.
Cancun Connectivity and Cost
For the month of January, there are 40 U.S. cities and 16 Canadian cities that fly nonstop to Cancun. Notable U.S. cities with direct flights embrace Miami, New York City, Atlanta, Los Angeles, and Seattle. Notable Canadian cities with direct flights embrace Toronto, Montreal, and Vancouver. Below are some costs for a round-trip ticket to Cancun from January 14th to January 21st.
Toronto to Cancun Round-Trip (YYZ to CUN)
- Price: $512
- Airline: Air Transat
- Luggage: Free Carry On, $54 Checked Bag
New York City to Cancun Round-Trip (JFK to CUN)
- Price: $356
- Airline: American Airlines
- Luggage: Free Carry On, $60 Checked Bag
Punta Cana Connectivity and Cost
For the month of January, there are 20 U.S. cities and eight Canadian cities that fly nonstop to Punta Cana. Notable U.S. cities with direct flights embrace Miami, New York City, Atlanta, Austin, and Chicago. The east coast has the higher hand for flights to Punta Cana. There aren’t any direct flights to Punta Cana additional west than Austin, Texas, for the month of January.
Notable Canadian cities with direct flights embrace Toronto, Montreal, and Quebec City. Below are some costs for a round-trip ticket to Punta Cana from January 14th to January 21st.
Toronto to Punta Cana Round-Trip (YYZ to PUJ)
- Price: $569
- Airline: Air Canada
- Luggage: Free Carry On, $46 Checked Bag
New York City to Punta Cana Round-Trip (JFK to PUJ)
- Price: $470
- Airline: JetBlue
- Luggage: Free Carry On, $60 Checked Bag
Flights: Who Wins?
Cancun is the winner on the subject of each flight connectivity and flight costs. While flights to Punta Cana aren’t overwhelmingly costlier, Cancun persistently has decrease costs. Also, Cancun has double the variety of direct flights to each the U.S. and Canada. Cancun additionally has additional reaching nonstop flights, whereas Punta Cana solely goes as far west as Austin, Texas. As Punta Cana continues to develop in reputation, we are going to doubtless see extra cities providing direct flights. For now, nonetheless, Cancun is cheaper and simpler to fly to.
One key indication of the overall inhabitants’s curiosity in one thing is how many individuals seek for it on Google. To see how folks have been in Cancun and Punta Cana during the last yr, we in contrast the 2 utilizing Google Trends.
Looking on the graph above, we are able to see that for the previous yr, Punta Cana has been about half as common as Cancun on the subject of Google searches. However, this doesn’t essentially imply that Cancun is healthier, merely that it’s looked for extra usually. Also, this solely takes into consideration searches throughout the United States.
The Bottom Line
Cancun and Punta Cana each provide unimaginable all-inclusive experiences for vacationers heading for hotter climate and sandy shores. Which one comes out on high will in the end be a choice for every particular person traveler.
Cancun is healthier related and cheaper to fly to, affords infinite actions, and has world-class seashores with unimaginable facilities proper alongside the shore. If you’re after easy accessibility to actions, late-night events, and a extra full of life vibe, Cancun is for you.
Punta Cana has cheaper lodging, affords extra secluded seaside experiences, and caters to vacationers who get pleasure from adventuring open air once they aren’t enjoyable at one in every of its luxurious all-inclusive properties. If you’re after a location that feels much less developed and extra genuine, Punta Cana is for you.
Both locations provide superb experiences that will probably be remembered for a lifetime, and both one can be nicely value a go to. Punta Cana and Cancun are each winners in our ebook. The finest recommendation we can provide vacationers questioning which one to decide on can be… select each!
This article initially appeared on Travel Off Path. For the newest breaking information that may have an effect on your subsequent journey, please go to: Traveloffpath.com
↓ Join the neighborhood ↓
The Travel Off Path Community FB group has all the newest reopening information, conversations, and Q&A’s occurring every day!
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR LATEST POSTS
Enter your e mail deal with to subscribe to Travel Off Path’s newest breaking journey information, straight to your inbox
Disclaimer: Current journey guidelines and restrictions can change with out discover. The choice to journey is in the end your duty. Contact your consulate and/or native authorities to substantiate your nationality’s entry and/or any modifications to journey necessities earlier than touring. Travel Off Path doesn’t endorse touring towards authorities advisories